banner photo:

"Each individual should allow reason to guide his conduct, or like an animal, he will need to be led by a leash."
Diogenes of Sinope

Banner photo
Thousand Flowers tapestry (15th Century) - Beaune, France (detail)

Sunday, July 25, 2010

Time for libertarians to stand up for Tony Clement

I'm the first person to admit that the Conservatives have made some boneheaded moves while in office, but the outrage being churned up over the census issue needs to be confronted head-on by libertarian Conservatives. This is a libertarian move by a government that often seems deaf to pleas that the state be made less intrusive in the lives of its citizens, so when they actually make a move in that direction, we need to defend it vigorously.

I can't frame this issue better than George Jonas did in Saturday's National Post. In a column titled None of their business, he wrote about his encounters with the Statistics Canada bureaucracy that assures us that the long-form census is a "necessary evil" and they only have our best interests at heart:
I'm making light of my conversation with Census Canada, but in fact it's not a laughing matter. For an official to suggest--and perhaps sincerely believe-- that it's not intrusive and impertinent for Census Canada to ask citizens their roommates' or common law partners' name (and therefore sex), or that the government "needs" such information for "statistical purposes," shows that by now our bureaucrats suffer from more than simple arrogance or insensitivity. They sincerely believe that if they "need" to know the name and sex of our roommates, we ought to tell them. After all, they aren't asking out of idle curiosity but for reasons of state. If that doesn't override our feeble rights to piffle such as privacy or dignity, what does?

Our social-engineering elites and martinets suffer from Sun-king-ism, the kind of megalomania that made Louis XIV utter "l'etat, c'est moi." Scary enough coming from the Sun King. When it starts coming from Assistant Chief Statisticians, it's time for the men with the butterfly nets.

Now that Tony Clement has started fixing up the asylum, a few candidates for the padded cells are coming to their senses. Oh, well, perhaps we went a tad overboard, they say. Maybe that long census form was a little too long. Maybe we don't need to ask all those questions. Hey, Tony, how about half? What do you say?

Evil, yes, in other words; necessary, not so much.

Call it half-unnecessary evil. I rest my case.


wilson said...

To stand up for Clement,
Conservative bloggers have to venture out of the saftey of their own environment.

'Progressive hospitality' on progressive 'owned' blogs
(kady at CBC, Wherry/Wells at Macleans, G&M, for example) is pretty brutal, that's an understatement.

Ignore the charactor assasination name calling,
make your point short and sweet, and factual, stay on topic.

Anonymous said...

Good post, Eric.
I am an aging heterosexual female. I totally agree with you.
I like my privacy. Lack of privacy I equate with the socialist states.